This paper examines opera as a historical and philosophical medium through which societies have regulated voice as a core site of legitimacy, identity, and human authenticity. Drawing on Identity Group Theory (IGT), it argues that opera has long functioned not merely as aesthetic performance, but as a structured arena in which vocal expression mediates sacred authority, political legitimacy, emotional authenticity, and cultural belonging. Through selected readings of Bellini’s Norma, Wagner’s Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, and Puccini’s Tosca and Madama Butterfly, the paper demonstrates how operatic traditions have historically constructed voice as an allocative mechanism within distinct identity economies. These works collectively reveal voice as a medium through which institutional authority, artistic legitimacy, social recognition, and human value are negotiated. Against this historical framework, contemporary developments in artificial intelligence—including synthetic voice generation, algorithmic reproduction, and AI-mediated performance—pose profound challenges to longstanding systems of authenticity, authorship, and cultural legitimacy. As artificial intelligence increasingly destabilizes assumptions about human uniqueness and expressive authority, opera offers a uniquely rich conceptual archive for analysing emerging crises in identity economies. By placing operatic voice in dialogue with contemporary AI, this paper positions IGT as an interdisciplinary framework for understanding technological disruptions to recognition, performative legitimacy, and cultural value in the twenty-first century.

Authors:
Derek Barker-Ciganik, University of Vienna, Austria

---

Conference Comments & Feedback

Place a comment using your LinkedIn profile

[wplinkpress_comments]

Share this Presentation

Share this...

Facebook

Pinterest

Twitter

Linkedin

Posted by James Alexander Gordon

Last updated: 2023-02-23 23:45:00

All Posts